Telling lies is not exactly the best way to Santa’s heart, right?

That’s where things begin in Freeform’s holiday film, The Truth About Christmas. In the original movie, we meet political consultant Jillian (New Girl‘s Kali Hawk), who is able to spin anything and often bends the truth more than a little bit. But she soon finds her life turned upside-down when a run-in with a department store Santa has her telling the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth.